This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase a product using one of our affiliate links we will receive a small commission from your purchase which helps us to provide this website as a service to you for free. We appreciate your support!
When we rescued our puppy, Elle, we did like most families and headed over to one of the big chain pet stores to pick up all of the necessities. During that trip, we walked down the dog treat aisle and I was completely overwhelmed. There were SO many different brands. So many claim to be healthier than the next.
After way too much time reading ingredients on way too many packages and trying to make the best decision for Elle, I chose a bag and headed home. As awesome as these treats sounded and looked, Elle wasn’t in love with them. She would take it, walk to the other end of the house, drop it, and walk away.
But… It was a treat. It had “real” ingredients. But she wasn’t impressed. A week or so later, my Aunt came over with her dog and a bag full of treats that she made herself from only four ingredients. She gave one to Elle and I was shocked to see her reaction. Elle loved it! She wanted more. I needed that recipe! No more store-bought dog treats for our dog! From now on, we are sticking with these homemade peanut butter dog treats.
Safety First
Before I continue, I want to stress the importance of making sure that your dog (or the person making it) isn’t allergic to anything in this recipe. When buying peanut butter, it’s very important to make sure that xylitol is not one of the ingredients, as this is toxic for dogs.
Also, please make sure that the pumpkin puree is 100% pumpkin and does not contain any other ingredients that may be unhealthy for dogs.
Why Homemade?
We care about the type of food we give our kids, so why would our dog be any different? She is part of our family, after all. I wanted to make sure that what we are giving her isn’t hurting her. We want her to live a long, healthy life. And if I have to spend a little bit of time every couple of weeks, it’s totally worth it for me.
What I love about these treats is that they are so easy to make. It’s only four ingredients. And no matter what your cooking or baking level is, you can make them!
Use an electric mixer to mix peanut butter, pumpkin and eggs.
Slowly add in flour, in 1/2 cup increments.
Dough should not be sticky, so adjust the amount of flour accordingly.
Put your finished dough on the silicone mat. If you don’t have a mat, you can sprinkle some flour on a flat surface, like your counter.
Use your rolling pin to roll the dough to approximately a 1/4 inch thickness.
Use cookie cutters and place your cut treats on the cookie sheet.
Bake 20-25 minutes, until edges are golden.
Transfer to a cooling rack and make sure they are completely cool.
Notes
Since these dog treats contain eggs, we recommend refrigerating them. If you make a large batch, you can also freeze them and move them to the refrigerator as needed.
We hope that your dog loves these as much as Elle does. If you do make them, or have another homemade dog treat recipe, I’d love to hear about it in the comments below!
Hi! I’m Heather, Mom of 3, professional snack opener, the only person who knows where everything is in my house and part-time magician (I can turn a bunch of candy into a gift basket and everyone thinks it’s amazing). I share a mix of parenting moments, easy recipes, crafts, and DIY home decor projects.
Around here, we love turning ordinary stuff into extraordinary gifts, from candy box baskets and birthday punch boards to homemade advent calendars and other crafty chaos that somehow always works out.
Welcome to The Super Mom Life — where the projects are fun, the coffee is strong, and the laughter is pretty much required for survival. Don't forget to follow us on social media!
I think we need to make a batch of these for our own rescue pup, Brownie! Maybe I’ll make them today while she spends the day at work with my husband. It’s their new thing but I work from home and I miss her when she goes!
Get Recipe Ingredients
Get Recipe Ingredients
Wow This is gonna be so good, My furbaby gonna be loving this for sure. Thanks for sharing an awesome recipe treats for our furbaby.
Oh these are going to be great for adding some variety to the type of treats the dogs get. I love how simple the ingredients are!
Now these sound like some great treats to make for your dog. I can imagine them going down a treat with them as well.
Homemade is DEFINITELY always best!! 🙂 I am sure your pooch appreciates this recipe!
Those sound like super yummy dog treats. Marshmallow is going to love when I make these for her.
I think we need to make a batch of these for our own rescue pup, Brownie! Maybe I’ll make them today while she spends the day at work with my husband. It’s their new thing but I work from home and I miss her when she goes!
This recipe would be perfect to make for my friends and family who have a fur baby. I know they would love it.