Air Fried Oreos vs. Deep Fried Oreos Challenge

deep fried oreos vs. air fried oreos challenge
Category: Desserts
Published Date: 10/28/2019
Comments: 56

This post may contain affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

Share with a friend!

 

I have a confession. I only go to the fair for the food. Specifically, deep fried Oreos. They are my weakness. There’s something about the fried, warm, ooey-gooey treats that I can’t resist. But we haven’t been to the fair in a while and well, I’m trying to eat healthier. So what’s a girl to do?

Now that I have an air fryer, I figured I would try to recreate those yummy deep fried Oreos from the fair. I went searching for the perfect air fried Oreo recipe and was disappointed with the options. Most suggest that you buy crescent dough from the refrigerated section of your local supermarket. And while they sounded like a good idea, they just didn’t taste the same.

When I told my family that I was going to try to find a new option, they begged me to just stick with the deep fried version. Which gave me an idea… why not make it into a little contest and see which is better… deep fried Oreos or air fried Oreos.  Read on to see which ones they preferred!

deep fried oreos in a basket
  • Save

Deep Fried Oreos

I’m pretty sure we nailed these. They were so close to the deep fried Oreos we buy at the fair, we couldn’t believe it.  If you love funnel cakes and Oreos, this is the perfect marriage of flavors. All you need is oil, powdered sugar, Oreos and our recipe for homemade funnel cakes (if you want a shortcut, you can also use the store-bought funnel cake mix)!

These deep fried Oreos are exactly like the ones you get at the fair. Ooey-gooey and so delicious!
  • Save

Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
deep fried oreos in a basket
  • Save

Deep Fried Oreos


Description

Just like the deep fried Oreos you buy at the fair, they are ooey-gooey and so delicious!


Ingredients

Scale

Instructions

  1. Pour approx 1½ inch of oil into a pan and heat on medium-high heat. You want the oil to be higher than the Oreo.
  2. Mix funnel cake batter according to our directions or packaging (most will just have you add water).
  3. Once oil is hot, dip an Oreo cookie into the batter and make sure it’s fully covered
  4. Place batter dipped Oreo into the heated oil. Once you start to see it turn brown (it will be 1-2 minutes), remove and place on a paper towel, on top of a plate. Repeat.
  5. Top with powdered sugar and serve warm.
  • Category: Dessert

stack of deep fried oreos
  • Save

plate of deep fried oreos
  • Save

Air Fried Oreos

This was definitely not as easy as I thought it would be. I scoured the internet for options aside from the store bought crescent dough. Pancake batter? Too runny. Funnel cake mix? Also too runny. I thought about adding flour to either one of those to try to form a dough that can be rolled, but I didn’t want it to taste too floury.

Then, as I was watching a baking competition on tv last weekend, it hit me… PUFF PASTRY DOUGH! Perfect! But have you ever seen them make it? It takes time. You have to chill it, roll it, fold it, chill it again, let it proof. Who has time for all that? When you want fried Oreos, you want them now, not in 14 hours. But guess what?! The store sells puff pastry dough in the freezer section!

They are super flaky and lack the grease that the deep fried Oreos have.

Finally an air fried Oreo recipe that can compete with the deep fried Oreos we get at the fair!
  • Save

air fried oreos in a basket
  • Save

Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
air fried oreos in a basket
  • Save

Air Fried Oreos


Description

Love fried Oreos but trying to stay away from deep fried foods? These air fryer Oreos are crispy on the outside and ooey-gooey on the inside!


Ingredients

Scale
  • 1 pkg Oreos
  • 1 pkg puff pastry dough
  • powdered sugar
  • chocolate syrup

Instructions

  1. Remove the puff pastry dough from the box and let thaw, according to package.
  2. You'll find that the dough is folded into three parts. Using a pizza cutter, separate those three parts and then cut each of those into 4 equal squares.
  3. Using a square of dough, place an Oreo in the center, fold each corner into center of the oreo and pinch any open areas. The Oreo should be fully covered.
  4. Place 4 dough wrapped Oreos into the air fryer basket. Make sure they aren't touching. Cook on 400° for 8 minutes. Repeat.
  5. Top with powdered sugar and drizzle chocolate syrup. Serve warm.
  • Category: Dessert

stack of air fried oreos
  • Save

plate of air fried oreos
  • Save

close up of air fried oreos with chocolate drizzle and powdered sugar
  • Save

Which One Was Best?

So, which do you think was the bigger hit? Believe it or not, it was a tie! And our youngest, she would have been the tie breaker, but she couldn’t choose a favorite because she liked them both so much.

If you are a fried Oreo fan, I’d love for you to try these recipes and let me know which you prefer! Don’t forget to check out all of our kid friendly recipes!

Two delicious recipes for fried Oreos, one deep fried and one air fried. But which one will win my family's heart?
  • Save

 

Share with a friend!

Image

Hello There!

I'm so honored that you've found us! I'm Heather, a Mom of 3 who blogs about parenting, food, occasional travel and how I overcame my daily struggle with anxiety. I miss sleeping and rely on coffee and laughter to get me through the day. I hope you enjoy and visit often!

Leave a Reply


  1. Pingback: Air Fryer Artichoke Hearts with Garlic Aioli - The Super Mom Life

  2. I can’t remember if I have ever had something like this before, but I think they have had them at our local fair. Sounds like the ultimate junk food!

  3. I LOVE THIS idea!!!! I have to try it, I love oreos but haven’t ever fried them! Now I need to try both ways!

  4. These both look amazing! And I can see how it would be a tie. Choosing a favorite fried Oreo would be like choosing a favorite child! 🙂

  5. Confession, I’ve never tried a fried oreo though I’ve heard of them. I wish I could try one of each and taste the difference myself. I would have thought a pie crust dough instead of cresent dough honestly, but the funnel cake batter is a much better idea! I’m so tempted to get an air fryer this season!

  6. That’s quite an interesting recipe. I don’t think I’ve tried Air fried and Deep-fried Oreos before but that looks quite delicious.

  7. wooooow. the first picture made me woooow! I would so love to taste both air fried Oreos and deep fried Oreos. I’m drooling right now.

  8. This looks so indulgent and moreish! Both my kids love Oreos and this just pushes it up a notch. I would love to try both the air fried and deep fried Oreos to see which was best

  9. I’ve never heard of fried oreos before! These sound and look amazing! I’m always looking for new air fryer recipes so I’m going to pin this!

  10. Tried the Air Fried Oreos tonight and they’re SO good! My kids are big fans of fried Oreos at fairs in the summer and this was just a perfect treat. No frying and super easy!

  11. I would vote for air fried oreos! It’s healthier and less oil. Much tastier too!

  12. Oh man, my husband really wants an air fryer because he thinks it’d be cool and once he sees that you can do fried Oreos in this he’s going to flip haha! It looks so yummy and that’s cool it’s a tie!

  13. The air fried looks fluffy, more like something my family would enjoy! Thank you for sharing such great recipes!

  14. Oh wow! We used to serve these in a restaurant I worked at in Illinois and I love that you made a healthier take on it! They are SO GOOD.

    1. Post
      Author
  15. I have never heard about deep fried Oreos before. You have made me very curious, I’d love to try them out. I don’t have an air fryer so it will have to be deep fried for me.

  16. This is awesome. I had no idea I could make Fried Oreos like this. Now, I am off to get some puff pastry so I can give this a try.

  17. I like both versions so I can’t help you with the stats. Haha. Air fried would be healthier but I can’t say no if someone offers me a deep fried one.

  18. oh my! Well I just found out that Oreos are Vegan the other day, so I may very well have to try this!!

  19. I never knew there was such a thing as deep fried Oreos! They look delicious. The air fried ones look great as well!

  20. that’s good to hear the air fried were not as greasy. i have never had either b/c they sound so sweet but if i had to choose i would go for the air fried.

  21. Well played indeed! Still catching up on this air frier technology. Good to know no good recipe goes unturned;)

  22. I just had my first fried oreo EVER a couple of weeks ago. I plan on getting my husband an air fryer for Christmas, so we’ll have to try these with the kids for sure!

  23. This is so awesome looking pastries with sweets inside! I have never done any thing like that. Time has come to follow your recipe.

  24. this is what heaven looks like my gawd. I am afraid to make this because I will eat all but this is a must. Pinning now

  25. I love the way that air fried Oreos look like they have so much less grease. I’ll definitely be trying that recipe.

  26. Wow, these sure look amazing. I have never tried deep fried Oreos before. This is something I’ve always wanted to try though. They sound delicious.

  27. Wow, these OREOs look way too good! I have never tried a fried OREO but I sure do want to about now!

  28. I’ve heard of deep-fried Oreos, but not air-fried. I would like to try this challenge!

  29. Wow, I never knew you can air-fried or deep-fried oreo! I love the idea and I will choose to air-fried as I just have gotten a Phillip air-fryer recently.

  30. I know that my family would love these. I love the idea of puff pastry instead of deep frying.

  31. I am very excited about this recipe. I love finding healthy alternatives that taste just as good as the original. I actually prefer that less greasy feel.

  32. Ohhh this is one of my favorite fair foods. Gosh, I dunno if I should try to make them at home that could be dangerous!

  33. Oh my, I’ve never heard of deep fried or air fried Oreos. Both sound like a wicked lovely weakness. I’ll have to try them both!

  34. I would love to try both to check out the difference myself. I love fried stuff, especially fried Oreos.

  35. Fried oreo? It is undoubtedly the coolest and most original idea I’ve read. I’m going to make these for Halloween.

  36. Ooh I recently got an air fryer so need to try this! I love that you can enjoy fried food with less fat! Great to know they tasted really similar!

  37. They both look and sound delicious, but I love the lack of grease that comes with air frying. I can’t wait to give them a try. I’ve been looking for something new to make.

  38. The air fried Oreos sound like the winner to me. I’ve always loved the flavor of this dessert, but I never liked all that grease.